How to deal with burrs after machining


Release time:

2021-05-12

【Summary】Burrs after machining are quite annoying, but don't worry! Here is a solution. The metal cutting process is often accompanied by the generation of burrs. The presence of burrs not only reduces the machining accuracy and surface quality of the workpiece, affecting the product's performance, but can sometimes even lead to accidents. To address the issue of burrs, people usually use a deburring process. Deburring is a non-productive process that not only increases product costs and extends the production cycle but also improper removal of burrs can lead to the scrapping of the entire product, resulting in economic losses. This article first systematically analyzes the main factors affecting the formation of burrs in end milling and discusses methods and techniques to reduce and control milling burrs from structural design to the entire manufacturing process. 1. Main Forms of Burrs in End Milling According to the cutting motion - tool cutting edge burr classification system, the burrs generated during the end milling process mainly include burrs on both sides of the main cutting edge, burrs in the direction of side cutting, burrs in the direction of bottom cutting, and burrs in the direction of entry and exit feed, totaling five forms (see Figure 1). Image Figure 1 Burrs formed during end milling Generally speaking, burrs in the direction of bottom cutting are characterized by larger size and difficulty in removal compared to other burrs. Therefore, this article focuses on burrs in the direction of bottom cutting as the main research object. Based on the different sizes and shapes of burrs in the direction of bottom cutting during end milling, they can be further divided into three types: Type I burrs (larger size, difficult to remove, higher removal cost), Type II burrs (smaller size, can be left or easily removed), and Type III burrs, which are negative burrs (as shown in Figure 2). Image Figure 2 Types of burrs in the direction of bottom cutting during milling 2. Main Factors Affecting the Formation of Burrs in End Milling The formation of burrs is a very complex material deformation process. Various factors such as the material properties of the workpiece, geometric shape, surface treatment, tool geometry, tool cutting trajectory, tool wear, cutting parameters, and the use of coolant directly affect the formation of burrs. Figure 3 is a causal control diagram of the factors affecting milling burrs. Under specific milling conditions, the shape and size of end milling burrs depend on the combined effects of various influencing factors, but different factors have different impacts on the formation of burrs. Image Figure 3 Causal control diagram of burr formation in milling 1. Tool Entry/Exit Generally, the burrs produced when the tool exits the workpiece are larger than those produced when the tool enters the workpiece. 2. Flat Cutting Angle The flat cutting angle has a significant impact on the formation of burrs in the direction of bottom cutting. The flat cutting angle is defined as the angle between the direction of cutting speed (the vector composition of tool speed and feed speed) at a point perpendicular to the tool axis when the cutting edge rotates out of the workpiece terminal surface and the direction of the workpiece terminal surface. The direction of the workpiece terminal surface points from the tool entry point to the tool exit point. As shown in Figure 5, Ψ is the flat cutting angle, with a range of 0°.

                                    How to deal with burrs after machining

Burrs after machining are very annoying, but don't worry! Here is a solution. The metal cutting process is often accompanied by the generation of burrs. The presence of burrs not only reduces the machining accuracy and surface quality of the workpiece, affecting the product's performance, but can also lead to accidents. To address the issue of burrs, people usually use a deburring process. Deburring is a non-productive process that not only increases product costs and extends production cycles but also improper removal of burrs can lead to the scrapping of the entire product, resulting in economic losses.

This article first systematically analyzes the main factors affecting the formation of burrs in end milling and discusses methods and techniques to reduce and control milling burrs from structural design to the entire manufacturing process.

1. Main forms of burrs in end milling

According to the classification system of burrs based on cutting motion - tool cutting edge, the burrs generated during the end milling process can be mainly classified into five forms: burrs on both sides of the main cutting edge, burrs in the direction of side cutting, burrs in the direction of bottom cutting, and burrs in the direction of entry and exit feed (see Figure 1).

Image

Figure 1 Burrs formed during end milling
Generally speaking, burrs in the direction of bottom cutting are larger and more difficult to remove compared to other burrs. Therefore, this article focuses on burrs in the direction of bottom cutting as the main research object.
 
According to the different sizes and shapes of burrs in the direction of bottom cutting during end milling, they can be divided into three types: Type I burrs (larger size, difficult to remove, higher removal cost), Type II burrs (smaller size, can be left unremoved or easily removed), and Type III burrs, which are negative burrs (as shown in Figure 2).

Image

Figure 2 Types of burrs in the direction of bottom cutting during milling

2. Main factors affecting the formation of burrs in end milling

The formation of burrs is a very complex material deformation process. Various factors such as the material properties of the workpiece, geometric shape, surface treatment, tool geometry, tool cutting trajectory, tool wear, cutting parameters, and the use of coolant directly affect the formation of burrs. Figure 3 shows the influence factors diagram for end milling burrs. Under specific milling conditions, the shape and size of end milling burrs depend on the combined effects of various influencing factors, but different factors have different impacts on the formation of burrs.

Image

Figure 3 Causal control diagram for burr formation during milling
1. Tool entry/exit
Generally, the burrs produced when the tool exits the workpiece are larger than those produced when the tool enters the workpiece.
2. Flat cutting angle
The flat cutting angle significantly influences the formation of burrs in the direction of the bottom cutting edge. The flat cutting angle is defined as the angle between the direction of cutting speed (the vector sum of tool speed and feed speed) at a point perpendicular to the tool axis when the cutting edge exits the end face of the workpiece and the direction of the workpiece end face. The direction of the workpiece end face is from the tool entry point to the tool exit point. As shown in Figure 5, Ψ represents the flat cutting angle, which ranges from 0° to 180°.
Experimental results show that the height of burrs changes with the cutting depth, meaning that as the cutting depth increases, burrs transition from Type I to Type II. The minimum cutting depth that produces Type II burrs is referred to as the limit cutting depth, denoted as dcr. Figure 6 shows the influence of flat cutting angle and cutting depth on burr height when processing an aluminum alloy.

Image

Figure 6 Burr forms with flat cutting angle and cutting depth
As shown in Figure 6, the larger the flat cutting angle, the greater the limit cutting depth; when the flat cutting angle exceeds 120°, the size of Type I burrs increases, and the limit cutting depth for transitioning to Type II burrs also increases. Therefore, a smaller flat cutting angle promotes the formation of Type II burrs, as a smaller Ψ enhances the support stiffness of the end face, making it more difficult for burrs to form.

The magnitude and direction of the feed speed have a significant impact on both the magnitude and direction of the resultant speed v, which in turn affects the flat cutting angle and burr formation. Therefore, as the feed speed and the exit edge offset angle α increase, Ψ decreases, which is more favorable for suppressing the formation of larger burrs (as shown in Figure 7).

Image

Figure 7 The influence of feed direction on burr formation
3. Tool tip exit sequence EOS
In the end milling process, the size of burrs largely depends on the exit sequence of the tool tip. As shown in Figure 8: Point A is on the secondary cutting edge, Point C is on the main cutting edge, and Point B is the tip of the tool. Assuming the tool tip is sharp, i.e., not considering the radius of the tool tip arc. If the B-C edge exits the workpiece first, and the A-B edge exits later, the chips hinge on the machined surface, and as milling progresses, the chips are pushed out of the workpiece, forming larger burrs in the direction of bottom cutting. If the A-B edge exits the workpiece first, and the B-C edge exits later, the chips hinge on the transition surface and are cut out of the workpiece, forming smaller burrs in the direction of bottom cutting.
Experiments show that:
① The tool tip exit sequence that causes burr sizes to increase in order is ABC/BAC/ACB/BCA/CAB/CBA.
② The results produced by EOS are the same; however, under the same exit sequence, the burr sizes produced by ductile materials are larger than those produced by brittle materials. The tool tip exit sequence is not only related to the tool geometry but also to factors such as feed amount, milling depth, workpiece geometric size, and cutting conditions, which collectively influence the formation of burrs.

Image

Figure 8 Tool tip exit sequence and burr formation
4. Influence of other factors
① Milling parameters, milling temperature, cutting environment, etc., also have a certain impact on the formation of burrs. Some main factors such as feed speed, milling depth, etc., are reflected through the flat cutting angle theory and tool tip exit sequence EOS theory, which will not be elaborated here.
The better the plasticity of the workpiece material, the easier it is to form Type I burrs. During the machining of brittle materials with end milling, if the feed rate or the plane cutting angle is large, it is conducive to the formation of Type III burrs (deficiency);
When the angle between the end face of the workpiece and the machined plane is greater than a right angle, the increased stiffness of the end face can suppress the formation of burrs;
The use of cutting fluid is beneficial for extending tool life, reducing tool wear, lubricating the milling process, and thereby reducing burr size;
Tool wear has a significant impact on the formation of burrs. When the tool wears to a certain extent, the radius of the tool tip increases, resulting in larger burr sizes in the tool withdrawal direction, and burrs will also form in the tool entry direction. The mechanism requires further in-depth research.
Other factors, such as tool materials, also have a certain impact on the formation of burrs. Under the same cutting conditions, diamond tools are more effective in suppressing burr formation compared to other tools.

III. Basic Approaches to Control the Formation of Milling Burrs

The formation of end milling burrs is influenced by various factors. It is not only related to the specific milling process but also to the workpiece structure, tool geometry, and other factors. To reduce end milling burrs, it is necessary to control and minimize burr generation from multiple aspects.
1. Reasonable Structural Design
The formation of burrs is largely influenced by the workpiece structure. Different workpiece structures result in significant differences in the shape and size of burrs at the edges after processing. If the workpiece material and surface treatment are predetermined, then the geometric shape and edges of the workpiece are important factors determining burr formation.

2. Appropriate Processing Sequence

The processing sequence also has a certain impact on the shape and size of end milling burrs. Different burr shapes and sizes result in varying amounts of deburring work and related costs. Therefore, selecting an appropriate processing sequence is an effective way to reduce deburring costs.

Image

Figure 9: Selection of Processing Sequence Control Method
In Figure 10a, if the hole is drilled first and then the plane is milled, larger cutting burrs are likely to form on the circumference of the hole; if the plane is milled first and then the hole is drilled, only smaller drilling entry burrs will be present on the circumference of the hole. Similarly, in Figure 10b, the burrs formed by milling the upper surface first and then milling the recessed profile are smaller than those formed by processing the recessed profile first and then milling the plane.
3. Avoid Tool Withdrawal
Avoiding tool withdrawal is an effective method to prevent burr formation, as tool withdrawal is the main factor in the formation of cutting direction burrs. Generally, burrs produced when the milling cutter withdraws from the workpiece are larger, while burrs produced when the cutter enters the workpiece are smaller. Therefore, during the machining process, efforts should be made to avoid the milling cutter withdrawing. As shown in Figure 4, the burrs produced in Figure 4b are smaller than those produced in Figure 4a.
4. Select Appropriate Cutting Path
From the previous analysis, it can be seen that when the plane cutting angle is less than a certain value, the resulting burr size is smaller. The plane cutting angle can be changed by altering the milling width, feed speed (size and direction), and rotational speed (size and direction). Therefore, selecting an appropriate cutting path can help avoid the generation of Type I burrs (see Figure 11).

Image

Figure 10: Control of Cutting Path Method
Figure 10a shows the traditional zigzag cutting path, where the shaded areas indicate locations where larger cutting direction burrs may form. Figure 10b uses an improved cutting path that can avoid the generation of cutting burrs. Although the cutting path in Figure 11b is slightly longer than that in Figure 10a, resulting in slightly more milling time, it does not require additional deburring processes. In contrast, the path in Figure 10a requires a significant amount of deburring time (although the shaded areas indicating burr generation are not many, all edges where burrs are located must be traversed during actual deburring). Therefore, overall, in terms of controlling burrs, the cutting path shown in Figure 10b is superior to that shown in Figure 10a.
5. Select Appropriate Milling Parameters
End milling parameters (such as feed per tooth, end milling width, end milling depth, and tool geometry angles) have a certain impact on burr formation.
The formation of end milling burrs is influenced by various factors, among which the main influencing factors include: tool withdrawal/entry, plane cutting angle, tool tip withdrawal sequence, milling parameters, etc. The final shape and size of the burrs are the result of the combined effects of various factors.
This article analyzes the main influencing factors of burr generation in milling from the aspects of workpiece structural design, processing technology arrangement, milling quantities, and tool selection. It proposes techniques, processes, and methods such as controlling the cutting path, selecting appropriate processing sequences, and improving structural design to suppress or reduce milling burrs, providing feasible technical solutions for actively controlling burr size, improving product quality, reducing costs, and shortening production cycles in milling processing.

TAG:


RELATED INFORMATION

ADD

Gengguantun Industrial Development Zone, Qingxian County, Hebei Province, China

WeChat applet

WeChat applet

Business License